The Great Debate: Raw vs. Gently Cooked Dog Food
Share
Hello, I'm Martina, your dog nutritionist, and I get this question all the time: "Which is better for my dog, raw or cooked meat?"
As a dog nutritionist, I get a lot of questions about what's best to feed our furry family members. It can be super confusing with all the different trends and terms out there, right? But don't worry, I'm here to simplify it for you!
When it comes to your dog's diet, the goal is whole foods – think minimally processed ingredients, just like you'd choose for yourself. That means we want to steer clear of highly processed kibble and canned foods, which often have fillers and gums that can really upset your dog's tummy.
You might also hear about "grain-free" or "ancestral" diets. While those can be buzzwords, what truly matters is that your dog's food is meat-forward, and nutritionally balanced with the right vitamin, minerals and oils. This means most of the protein should come from meat, not plants. Why? Because dogs need taurine, an essential amino acid found almost exclusively in meat proteins.
And here's a big one: always look for food labelled "human-grade." This isn't just a fancy term; it means every single ingredient is safe for human consumption and it's made in a human-grade facility. This is crucial because "feed-grade" foods can contain questionable byproducts from unhealthy animals. Yuck!
All this probably has you thinking about fresh, human-grade meat for your pup. But then the big question pops up: is raw or cooked meat better for your dog? Let's dive into it, because while raw diets are super popular, there are some important things to consider.
Raw vs. Gently Cooked: What's the Scoop?
Many folks wonder if dogs prefer raw meat because it’s closer to a wolf-like diet. While our dogs are indeed descended from wolves, -they are not carnivores but instead are something called facultative. Facultative carnivores, like dogs, prefer a meat-based diet for optimal nutrition but can adapt to consume plant matter or non-meat foods when necessary.
In fact, a dog’s digestive system clearly indicates that they are able to digest and absorb starch. Dogs can digest starch. They have evolved to digest starch-rich foods, unlike their wolf ancestors, and possess genes that allow for efficient starch digestion. This adaptation is thought to be a key factor in their domestication.
The answer to their preference really depends on your individual pooch! Both raw and gently cooked whole foods can be fantastic for your dog. However, I often lean towards meat-forward, human-grade whole foods cooked at low heat, and I have three main reasons why:
- Raw Meat's Pathogens: Just like any raw meat you handle in your kitchen, raw dog food comes with the risk of pathogens like Listeria and Salmonella. There's no cooking step to kill these off. This means you need to be super diligent about storing, preparing, and cleaning up after raw food, just like you would when making a steak dinner for yourself.
For households with little ones crawling around, elderly grandparents, or anyone with a compromised immune system, gently cooked fresh food can be a much safer choice. It's just as nutritionally sound for your dog but dramatically cuts down on pathogen risks.
If you do go the raw route, make sure the meat is fully thawed, and your dog eats it within a short time frame to prevent bacteria from growing. And always, always wash dog dishes thoroughly and immediately, and clean any surfaces the raw meat touches. Hand washing is key here!
- Cooked Food's Digestibility: While raw meat might seem more "natural," gently cooked meat can actually be easier for both you to handle and your dog to digest. Plus, it might even get those picky eaters excited! Our gently prepared meals are perfect for picky eaters.
Dogs need a good balance of nutrients. While many raw diets are 90%+ meat, that can mean they're also super high in fat, which can sometimes lead to digestive upset for some dogs. Gently cooked foods, on the other hand, often incorporate more healthy vegetables. These provide crucial fibre to aid digestion, making it a great option if your dog has a sensitive stomach.
And let's be real: cooking makes meat taste better! When meat gently simmers with other yummy and beneficial ingredients (like parsley for fresh breath!), it becomes tender, flavourful, and incredibly fragrant. A picky eater might simply prefer cooked food because it smells so amazing!
There's no definitive research showing whether raw or cooked meat is inherently more digestible for dogs, but there's plenty of evidence that whole food diets are far better digested than highly processed kibble or canned foods. So, whether you choose raw or gently cooked, opt for whole ingredients!
- Equal Whole Foods Nutrition: Raw foods are minimally processed, which is great. But gently cooked foods can deliver all the same fantastic whole food nutrition without the extra safe handling worries or potential tummy troubles that can come with raw meat.
And let's not forget: your dog won't get any nutrition from raw food if they simply won't eat it! Sometimes, the choice between raw and cooked comes down to what your dog actually loves.
Some brands use human-grade meat and cook it slowly using a "sous vide" method. This means the meat is simmered inside food-safe bags, locking in all those healthy nutrients and creating a naturally hydrating, collagen-rich gravy. This cooking method means you get nutrition that's on par with a raw food diet, but in a safer, tastier, and easier-to-manage format. Plus, it often has a longer shelf life in your fridge!
Making the Best Choice for Your Pup
Ultimately, a fresh, whole foods diet is the best choice for your dog. Gently cooked meat might not be "raw like a wolf would eat," but it's still minimally processed for optimal nutrition, and it's good for both your pet and for you, the human handling their food!
If your dog absolutely thrives on raw, and you're comfortable with the safe handling practices, then go for it! But if not, know that gentle cooking can really enhance flavour and fragrance, making it super tempting for your sweet pup. Plus, you get the benefits of fewer pathogens, a bit less fat, and often, more convenience from start to finish. No matter if dogs prefer cooked or raw meat, seeing a happy dog gobble up their dinner is the best reward. So, why not explore gently cooked options and see your pup's tail wag with delight?
You may also want to read my blog post: Why I Believe Fresh, Lightly Cooked Dog Food is Perfect for Your Dog
What do you think? Do you want to know more about either way to prepare human grade food for your dog? Reach out to me (Martina) at info@yourcaninenutritionist.com
Or, you can check out our pre-made human grade dog meals to see our full menu.